Description
Assessment Instructions
Select a journal article on the subject of supplements and write a summary paper reviewing the article. You are encouraged, but not required, to use Senchina’s 2013 article “Athletics and Herbal Supplements,” linked in the Resources, under the Library Resources heading, for this article review. Note: If you choose to review an article other than the “Athletics and Herbal Supplements” reading, you may need to do further research in order to fully address all of the topics required for this paper.
Address all of the following points in your article review:
- What are the main points presented in the article? What message is the author trying to convey? What are the specific areas of research and findings that the article highlights?
- How could the supplements discussed in the article affect cells and body systems?
- How are supplements used in different areas of athletics? Why are supplements currently unregulated? Based on your readings, do you think supplements should undergo more stringent testing? If so, how would this be monitored and paid for? Where in your life (or in the life of a friend or family member) is it important that supplements are tested? Note: Your answer to this question does not need to apply only to athletics.
- Crosscheck the information in your article with other sources. What do other sources say about the same concepts presented in the article? Are there discrepancies between the information from the article and from other sources?
- Complete an evaluation of your article, using either the Source Evaluation Form: Web Sites or the Source Evaluation Form: Journals and Books, both of which are linked in the Resources under the Capella Resources heading. Download the appropriate form and answer the questions.
- In an additional paragraph or two, answer the following questions:
- Would you consider this article to be a credible source of information on this topic? Why or why not?
Formatting Requirements
- Written communication: Written communication should be free of errors that detract from the overall message.
- APA formatting: References and citations should be formatted according to APA (6th edition) style and formatting.
- Font and font size: Times New Roman, 12-point.
- Length: Your paper should be between 500 and 700 words in length.
- Format: Either submit both the Article Review paper and the completed Source Evaluation Form, or write a paragraph into your paper addressing the questions from the form.
Suggested Resources
The following optional resources are provided to support you in completing the assessment or to provide a helpful context. For additional resources, refer to the Research Resources and Supplemental Resources in the left navigation menu of your courseroom.
Capella Resources
Click the links provided to view the following resources:
- Assessment 1 Context.
- Source Evaluation Form: Web Sites.
- Source Evaluation Form: Journals and Books.
- Evaluating Source Quality.
- How to Search the Library: The Basics.
- To become familiar with the academic writing process used at Capella, you are encouraged to complete the Personal Writing Assessment – Track 1. You are encouraged to take this assessment at least once during your undergraduate studies, and you may want to retake it later to see how your writing has improved. You may save or print your transcript once your assessment is complete.
Capella Multimedia
Click the links provided below to view the following multimedia pieces:
- Cell Structure and Function | Transcript.
- This presentation will introduce you to different types of cells and help you understand how the body works at a cellular level.
- Body System | Transcript.
- This presentation looks at various systems and functions that will be addressed in this course. This includes immunity, the endocrine system, and DNA biology, as well as the nervous, cardiovascular, muscular, and skeletal systems.
- Bone Remodeling | Transcript.
- This presentation focuses on the details of bone and bone growth.
- Muscle Contraction | Transcript.
- This presentation focuses on muscles and how they function and contract.
Library Resources
The following e-books or articles from the Capella University Library are linked directly in this course:
- Senchina, D. S. (2013). Athletics and herbal supplements. American Scientist, 101(2), 134–141.
- Brooks, A. (2007). Systems of our body. Delhi, IND: Global Media.
- “Muscular and Skeletal Systems.”
- Rogers, K. M. A., Scott, W. N, Warner, S., & Willis, B. (2011). Paramedics! Test yourself in anatomy and physiology. Maidenhead, GBR: Open University Press.
- Chapter 1, “The Human Cell.”
- Chapter 2, “Essential Biology and Biochemistry.”
- Chapter 4, “The Musculoskeletal System.”
- Singh, S. P., & Tomar, B. S. (2008). Cell biology. Meerut, IND: Global Media.
- Chapter 1, “The Cell.”
- Chapter 2, “Cell Metabolism.”
- Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. (2002). Lippincott professional guides: Anatomy & physiology (2nd ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Author.
- Chapter 1, “The Human Body.”
- Chapter 4, “Musculoskeletal System.”
- Van De Graaff, K. M., & Rhees R. W. (2001). Human anatomy and physiology. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
- Chapter 1, pages 1–3, “Introduction to the Human Body.”
- Chapter 2, “Cellular Chemistry.”
- Chapter 3, “Cell Structure and Function.”
- Chapter 4, “Tissues.”
- Chapter 6, “Skeletal System.”
- Chapter 7, “Muscle Tissue and the Mode of Contraction.”
- Chapter 20, “Metabolism and Temperature Regulation.”
- Chapter 22, “Water and Electrolyte Balance.”
Course Library Guide
A Capella University library guide has been created specifically for your use in this course. You are encouraged to refer to the resources in the BIO-FP1000 – Human Biology Library Guide to help direct your research.
Internet Resources
Access the following resources by clicking the links provided. Please note that URLs change frequently. Permissions for the following links have been either granted or deemed appropriate for educational use at the time of course publication.
- Anatomy & Physiology. (2014). Anatomy & physiology: A learning initiative (under construction). Retrieved from http://anatomyandphysiologyi.com/
- Anatomy & Physiology. (2014). A&P: Levels of structural organization. Retrieved from http://anatomyandphysiologyi.com/ap-levels-of-stru…
- BBC. (2014). Maintaining body temperature. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/science/…
- Biology-Online.org. (n.d.). Chemical composition of the body. Retrieved from http://www.biology-online.org/9/1_chemical_composi…
- Biology-Online.org. (n.d.). Homeostasis. Retrieved from http://www.biology-online.org/dictionary/Homeostas…
- Biology-Online.org. (n.d.). Physiological homeostasis. Retrieved from http://www.biology-online.org/4/1_physiological_ho…
- Biology-Online.org. (n.d.). Scientific method. Retrieved from http://www.biology-online.org/dictionary/Scientifi…
- Biology-Online.org. (n.d.). Temperature regulation in animals. Retrieved from http://www.biology-online.org/4/4_temperature_regu…
- Howtomedia, Inc. (2013). Muscular system anatomy. Retrieved from InnerBody.com Web site: http://www.innerbody.com/image/musfov.html#full-de…
- Howtomedia, Inc. (2013). Skeletal system anatomy. Retrieved from InnerBody.com Web site: http://www.innerbody.com/image/skelfov.html#full-d…
- The Nemours Foundation. (2014). Muscular Dystrophy. Retrieved from TeensHealth Web site: http://kidshealth.org/teen/diseases_conditions/bon…
- Purdue Online Writing Lab. (2013). Paraphrase: Write it in your own words. Retrieved from https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/619/01…
Bookstore Resources
The resources listed below are relevant to the topics and assessments in this course and are not required. These resources are available from the Capella University Bookstore. When searching the bookstore, be sure to look for the Course ID with the specific –FP (FlexPath) course designation.
- Ireland, K. A. (2012). Visualizing human biology (4th ed.). Danvers, MA: Wiley.
- Chapter 1, “What Is Life?” This chapter sets the stage for your exploration of the human body. Scientific knowledge and advances are obtained through the use of the scientific method, a systematic way of studying the natural world. Scientists use critical thinking and objective evaluation in their own studies and when assessing the work of others. You too must learn to evaluate information critically to determine the factual integrity and quality of the information you receive.
- Chapter 3, “Everyday Chemistry of Life.” Organic molecules, built on atoms of carbon and at least one hydrogen atom, are the building blocks that make up all living things. This chapter describes the four classes of biological molecules. Knowledge of these types of molecules is essential for understanding the structure and function of cells, tissues, and organ systems.
- Chapter 4, “Cells: Organization and Communication.” The human body contains trillions of cells. Each cell is highly organized, functioning and interacting to sustain life. This chapter explores how cells are built and how they operate—synthesizing molecules, bringing substances in, and releasing or keeping others out.
- Chapter 5, “Tissues.” Cells are organized into different tissues, organs, and organ systems. As you read through the specific organ systems in later chapters, you will learn more about these tissues. This chapter introduces tissue types and considers how cells and complex body parts function to maintain equilibrium or homeostasis.
- Chapter 6, “The Skeleto-Muscular System.” Besides providing an overview of the skeletal system, this chapter explains how bone functions as a living, dynamic tissue. This chapter also explores the structure and function of skeletal muscle to explain the mechanics of muscle contractions.
Article Review Scoring Guide
Article Review Scoring Guide
CRITERIA
NONPERFORMANCE
BASIC
PROFICIENT
DISTINGUISHED
Discuss how
supplements affect
cells and body
systems.
Does not list
supplements
that affect cells
and body
systems.
Lists supplements
that affect cells
and body
systems.
Discusses how
supplements affect
cells and body
systems.
Discusses specific supplements
that affect cells and body
systems in athletes, and how
they are currently being used in
sports.
Compare article with
multiple sources of
information about
the same concepts.
Does not
compare article
with other
sources of
information.
Compares article
with a single
source of
information, or
does not focus on
the same
concepts.
Compares article with
multiple sources of
information about the
same concepts.
Compares article with multiple
sources of information about
the same concepts, and
provides an analysis of the
similarities and differences.
Incorporate an
analysis of sources
into an article
review.
Does not
describe
sources for an
article review.
Describes
Incorporates an
sources, but does analysis of sources into
not incorporate an an article review.
analysis of
sources into an
article review.
Incorporates a clear, concise
and rich analysis of sources
into an article review, citing
credible sources that support
the analysis.
Compare the main
points presented
about supplements,
including specific
areas of research
and the findings.
Does not
discuss the
main points
presented
about
supplements.
Discusses the
main points
presented about
supplements but
does not include
specific areas of
research or the
findings.
Compares the main
points presented about
supplements, including
specific areas of
research and the
findings.
Compares the main points
presented about supplements,
including specific areas of
research and the findings, and
draws a conclusion regarding
the current state of the field of
supplement usage.
Examine the role of
supplements in
athletics and
discuss why
supplements are
currently
unregulated.
Does not
examine the
role of
supplements in
athletics or
discuss why
supplements
are currently
unregulated.
Describes the role
of supplements in
athletics, but does
not discuss why
supplements are
currently
unregulated.
Examines the role of
supplements in
athletics and discusses
why supplements are
currently unregulated.
Examines the role of
supplements in athletics and
discusses why supplements are
currently unregulated,
addressing the rationales
behind the arguments for and
against regulation.
Interpret whether or
not supplements
should undergo
more stringent
testing.
Does not
describe how
supplements
are tested.
Describes how
supplements are
tested, but does
not interpret
whether or not
they should
undergo more
stringent testing.
Interprets whether or
not supplements
should undergo more
stringent testing.
Interprets whether or not
supplements should undergo
more stringent testing, including
an assessment of both the
positive and negative
ramifications of more stringent
regulations.
Write coherently to
support a central
idea in appropriate
format with correct
grammar, usage,
and mechanics,
including correct
APA format and
citations.
Does not write
to support a
central idea.
Writes to support
a central idea but
the format is
inconsistent and
there are errors in
grammar, usage,
and mechanics.
Writes coherently to
support a central idea
in appropriate format
with correct grammar,
usage, and mechanics,
including correct APA
format and citations.
Writes coherently to support a
central idea in appropriate
format with correct grammar,
usage, and mechanics,
including correct APA format
and citations, and using
concise, clear, and thorough
language.
https://courserooma.capella.edu/bbcswebdav/institution/BIO-FP/BIO-FP1000/150701/Scoring_Guides/u01a1_scoring_guide.html
1/1
Running head: APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
1
The instructional and sample text in this template is informational. After reading the
information, please delete it, and use the document as a template for your own paper. To
keep the correct format, edit the running head, cover page, headings, and reference list
with your own information, and add your own body text. Save this template in a file for
future use and information.
The running head is an abbreviated title of the paper. The running head is located at the top of
pages of a manuscript or published article to identify the article for readers. The running head
should be a maximum of 50 characters, counting letters, punctuation, and spaces between words.
The words “Running head” are on the cover page but not on the rest of the document. The
running head title is all capital letters. Page 1 begins on the cover page. The entire document
should be double-spaced, have 1-inch margins on all sides, and use 12 point Times New Roman
font.
Full Title of Paper
Learner’s Full Name
Course Title
Assignment Title
Capella University
Month, Year
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
2
Abstract (As this section is optional, check with your instructor.)
An abstract is a brief, comprehensive summary of the contents of a paper. It allows readers to
quickly review the key elements of a paper without having to read the entire document. This can
be helpful for readers who are searching for specific information and may be reviewing many
documents. The abstract may be one of the most important paragraphs in a paper because readers
often decide if they will read the document based on information in the abstract. An abstract may
not be required in some academic papers; however, it can still be an effective method of gaining
the reader’s attention. For example, an abstract will not be required for Capella’s first course,
PSYC3002. The following sentences serve as an example of what could be composed as an
abstract for this paper: The basic elements of APA style will be reviewed, including formatting
of an APA style paper, in-text citations, and a reference list. Additional information will address
the components of an introduction, how to write effective paragraphs using the MEAL plan, and
elements of a summary and conclusion section of a paper.
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
3
APA Style Paper Template: A Resource for Academic Writing
Please change the titles in this document to fit your paper.
APA (American Psychological Association) style is most commonly used to cite sources
within the social sciences. APA style is used when writing papers in the psychology programs
offered at Capella University. This document serves as an APA style template for learners to use
when writing their own papers, as well as a resource containing valuable information that can be
used when writing academic papers. For more information on APA style, learners can refer to
the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association (American Psychological
Association, 2010a).
The author demonstrates in the first section of this paper how an introduction effectively
introduces the reader to the topic of the paper. In APA style, an introduction never gets a
heading. For example, this section did not begin with a heading titled “Introduction,” similar to
the following section, which is titled “Writing an Effective Introduction.” The following section
will explain in greater detail a model that can be used to effectively write an introduction in an
academic paper. The remaining sections of the paper will continue to address APA style and
effective writing concepts including section headings, organizing information, the MEAL plan,
the conclusion, and the reference list.
Writing an Effective Introduction
An effective introduction often consists of four main components including (a) the
position statement, thesis, or hypothesis, which describes the author’s main position; (b) the
purpose, which outlines the objective of the paper; (c) the background, which is general
information that is needed to understand the content of the paper; and (d) the approach, which is
the process or methodology the author uses to achieve the purpose of the paper. This information
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
4
will help readers understand what will be discussed in the paper. It can also serve as a tool to
grab the reader’s attention. Authors may choose to briefly reference sources that will be
identified later on in the paper as in this example (American Psychological Association, 2010a;
American Psychological Association, 2010b; Walker, 2008).
In an introduction, the writer will often present something of interest to capture the
reader’s attention and introduce the issue. Adding an obvious statement of purpose helps the
reader know what to expect, while helping the writer to focus and stay on task. For example, this
paper will address several components necessary to effectively write an academic paper
including (a) how to write an introduction, (b) how to write effective paragraphs using the
MEAL plan, and (c) how to properly use APA style.
Level One Section Heading is Centered, Bold, Uppercase and Lowercase
Using section headings can be an effective method of organizing an academic paper. The
section headings should not be confused with the running head, which is a different concept
described in the cover page of this document. Section headings are not required according to
APA style; however, they can significantly improve the quality of a paper. This is accomplished
because section headings help both the reader and the author.
Level Two Section Heading is Flush Left, Bold, Uppercase and Lowercase
The heading style recommended by APA consists of five levels (American Psychological
Association, 2010a, p. 62). This document contains two levels to demonstrate how headings are
structured according to APA style. Immediately before the previous paragraph, a Level 1
heading was used. That section heading describes how a Level 1 heading should be written,
which is centered, bold, and using uppercase and lowercase letters. For another example, see the
section heading “Writing an Effective Introduction” on page 3 of this document. The heading is
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
5
centered, bold, and uses uppercase and lowercase letters (compared to all uppercase in the
running head at the top of each page). If used properly, section headings can significantly
contribute to the quality of a paper by helping the reader who wants to understand the
information in the document, and the author who desires to effectively describe the information
in the document.
Section Headings Help the Reader
Section headings serve multiple purposes including (a) helping readers understand what
is being addressed in each section, (b) breaking up text to help readers maintain an interest in the
paper, and (c) helping readers choose what they want to read. For example, if the reader of this
document wants to learn more about writing an effective introduction, the previous section
heading clearly states that is where information can be found. When subtopics are needed to
explain concepts in greater detail, different levels of headings are used according to APA style.
Section Headings Help the Author
Section headings do not only help the reader, they help the author organize the document
during the writing process. Section headings can be used to arrange topics in a logical order, and
they can help an author manage the length of the paper. In addition to an effective introduction
and the use of section headings, each paragraph of an academic paper can be written in a manner
that helps the reader stay engaged. Capella University promotes the use of the MEAL plan to
serve this purpose.
The MEAL Plan
The MEAL plan is a model used by Capella University to help learners effectively
compose academic discussions and papers. Each component of the MEAL plan is critical to
writing an effective paragraph. The acronym MEAL is based on four components of a paragraph
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
6
(M = Main point, E = Evidence or Example, A = Analysis, and L = Link). The following section
includes a detailed description and examples of each component of the MEAL plan.
When writing the content sections of an academic paper (as opposed to the introduction
or conclusion sections), the MEAL plan can be an effective model for designing each paragraph.
A paragraph begins with a description of the main point, which is represented by the letter “M”
of the MEAL plan. For example, the first sentence of this paragraph clearly states the main point
is a discussion of the MEAL plan. Once the main point has been made, evidence and examples
can be provided.
The second component of a paragraph contains evidence or examples, which is
represented by the letter “E” in the MEAL plan. An example of this component of the MEAL
plan is actually (and ironically) this sentence, which provides an example of an example.
Evidence can be in the form of expert opinions from research. For example, evidence shows that
plagiarism can occur even when it is not intended if sources are not properly cited (Marsh,
Landau, & Hicks, 1997; Walker, 2008). The previous sentence provides evidence supporting
why evidence is used in a paragraph.
Analysis, which is represented by the letter “A” of the MEAL plan, should be based on
the author’s interpretation of the evidence. An effective analysis might include a discussion of the
strengths and weaknesses of the arguments, as well as the author’s interpretations of the evidence
and examples. If a quote is used, the author will likely provide an analysis of the quote and the
specific point it makes for the author’s position. Without an analysis, the reader might not
understand why the author discussed the information that the reader just read. For example, the
previous sentence was an analysis by the author of why an analysis is performed when writing
paragraphs in academic papers.
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
7
Even with the first three elements of the MEAL plan, it would not be complete without
the final component. The letter “L” of the MEAL plan refers to information that “links” the
current and the subsequent paragraphs. The link helps the reader understand what will be
discussed in the next paragraph. It summarizes the author’s reasoning and shows how the
paragraph fits together and leads (that is, links) into the next section of the paper. For example,
this sentence might explain that once the MEAL plan has been effectively used when writing the
body of an academic paper, the final section is the summary and conclusion section.
Summary and Conclusion
A summary and conclusion section, which can also be the discussion section of an APA
style paper, is the final opportunity for the author to make a lasting impression on the reader. The
author can begin by restating opinions or positions and summarizing the most important points
that have been presented in the paper. For example, this paper was written to demonstrate to
readers how to effectively use APA style when writing academic papers. Various components of
an APA style paper that were discussed or displayed in the form of examples include a running
head, title page, introduction section, levels of section headings and their use, in-text citations,
the MEAL plan, a conclusion, and the reference list.
APA STYLE PAPER TEMPLATE
8
References
American Psychological Association. (2010a). Publication manual of the American
Psychological Association (6th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
American Psychological Association. (2010b). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of
conduct. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from
http://www.apa.org/ethics/code/index.aspx
Marsh, R. L., Landau, J. D., & Hicks, J. L. (1997). Contributions of inadequate source
monitoring to unconscious plagiarism during idea generation. Journal of Experimental
Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 23(4), 886–897. doi: 10.1037/02787393.23.4.886
Walker, A. L. (2008). Preventing unintentional plagiarism: A method for strengthening
paraphrasing skills. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 35(4), 387–395. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com/docview/213904438?accountid=27965
Always begin a reference list on a new page. Use a hanging indent after the first line of each
reference. The reference list is in alphabetical order by first author’s last name. A reference list
only contains sources that are cited in the body of the paper, and all sources cited in the body of
the paper must be contained in the reference list.
The reference list above contains an example of how to cite a source when two documents are
written in the same year by the same author. The year is also displayed using this method for the
corresponding in-text citations as in the next sentence. The author of the first citation (American
Psychological Association, 2010a) is also the publisher, therefore, the word “Author” is used in
place of the publisher’s name.
When a digital object identifier (DOI) is available for a journal article, it should be placed at the
end of the citation. If a DOI is not available, a uniform resource locator (URL) should be used.
The Marsh, Landau, and Hicks (1997) reference is an example of how to cite a source using a
DOI. The Walker (2008) reference is an example of how to cite a source using a URL.
10/30/2018
Cells, Tissues, and Organs
Cells, Tissues, and Organs
Human biology covers all aspects of how the body is organized, how it operates, and how it changes over time,
including what is normal and abnormal for the organism as a whole. In this course, you will consider the hierarchy
of organization within the body.
Cell theory states that:
All organisms are composed of cells.
Cells are the fundamental unit of living things.
All cells come from preexisting cells.
The building blocks of cells—proteins, carbohydrates, lipids, and nucleic acids—must be understood in order to
appreciate how cells operate. You will consider the important aspects of the life of cells, including their internal
structures, their composition (building blocks), and the way they interact with their environments.
Humans are made of trillions of cells. The human body contains higher levels of organization that involve multiple
cells organized into tissues, organs, and organ systems. At each of these levels, cells must cooperate to maintain
conditions favorable to the body.
Homeostasis is the process of maintaining favorable conditions for all cells, and thus for the body as a whole.
Deviations from normal and changes in the environment trigger a homeostatic response through nervous signals,
hormones, tissues, and organs that readjust the body to its baseline conditions.
Tissues are defined as a collection of analogous cells. This grouping includes connective tissue, epithelial tissue,
nervous tissue, and muscular tissue. Multiple tissue types with different functions are arranged to form organs, and
multiple organs that carry out generalized body functions work together to form the organ systems that you will
learn about in this course. One of these organ systems, the skeletomuscular system, will be covered in this
assessment.
The Skeletomuscular System
The skeletal system gives the body its shape, protects soft organs, and interacts with muscles for movement. Bones
are one form of connective tissue composed of living cells and a fiber matrix hardened with calcium. Besides being
the skeletal framework, bones are the body’s reservoir of calcium, a mineral that is required for many functions,
including muscle contraction. Bones are constantly remodeled to adjust to the body’s needs. Thus, when we begin
an exercise program, our bones will become denser to accommodate the additional stress. A serious disease,
osteoporosis, results from depletion of minerals from bone. Here is another example of how interconnected our
systems are: exercise and nutrition can help minimize the effects of osteoporosis.
The muscular system gives us the ability to move by pulling on our bones. Skeletal muscles are attached to bone by
tendons. Many muscles exist in opposing pairs or groups, such that when one contracts the opposing muscle or
muscle group relaxes. Thus, when the bicep lifts our forearm, the tricep relaxes, and when the tricep pulls our
forearm down, the bicep relaxes. These skeletal muscles are also known as voluntary muscles. Involuntary
muscles, on the other hand, regulate our stomach and intestinal movements, blood vessel contractions, and many
other motor activities. The heart is a third type of muscle, called cardiac muscle.
All muscles contract through a similar mechanism, involving the participation of calcium, an energy source, and
gliding of muscle proteins along one another. Increased activity, such as strength training, increases muscle mass
by synthesis of additional contractile protein, increased blood supply, and enhancement of energy sources.
https://courserooma.capella.edu/bbcswebdav/institution/BIO-FP/BIO-FP1000/150701/Course_Files/cf_assessment_1_broader_context.html
1/1
Source Evaluation Form: Journals and Books
A Brief Checklist for Evaluating Journals and Books
(Adapted from Capella’s iGuide.)
Author
What are the author’s credentials, educational background, past writings, or experience?
Is the author associated with an institution or organization?
Date of Publication
When was the source published?
Is the source current or out of date for your topic?
Publisher
Note the publisher. If a university press publishes the source, it is likely to be scholarly.
Title of Journal or Book
Is this a scholarly journal or a popular journal?
Intended Audience
Is the publication aimed at a specialized audience or a general audience?
Objective Reasoning
Is the information covered fact, opinion, or propaganda? On what did you base your answer?
Is the author’s point of view objective and impartial? On what did you base your answer?
Coverage
Does the source extensively or marginally cover the topic?
Evaluation Checklist © Capella University 2003
1
Source Evaluation Form: Web Sites
A Brief Checklist for Evaluating Web Sites
(Adapted from Capella’s iGuide.)
Author or Web Site Producer
Is the author or producer a well-known and well-regarded name you recognize?
Is the author associated with an institution or organization?
Publisher – Organization or Sponsor
Is the name of an organization or sponsor given on the document you are reading?
Does the organization or sponsor have a reputation for expertise in the subject matter?
Does the Web site provide information describing the purpose of the organization or sponsor?
Point of View or Bias
Does this document reside on the server of an organization that has a political or philosophical
agenda?
Is the Web page a mask for advertising? Why was this written, and for whom?
Intended Audience
Is the publication aimed at a specialized audience or a general audience?
Content
Is the information covered fact, opinion, or propaganda? On what did you base your answer?
Is the content accurate? How do you know? Does the content need to be verified by other
resources?
1
Source Evaluation Form: Web Sites
Scope
Does the source extensively or marginally cover the topic?
Currency
How current is the information? How frequently is the resource updated? Is it a static
resource?
Evaluation Checklist © Capella University 2003
2
Purchase answer to see full
attachment
